Partner at AKD Lawyers
Practice Areas: Personal Injury, Insurance Claims
After a serious truck accident, the trucking company may seem like the obvious party to pursue. But what if the carrier has little insurance or cannot cover the full claim?
In some cases, the freight broker may also be responsible. A broker connects shippers with trucking companies, and if it carelessly chooses an unsafe carrier, it can face a negligent-selection claim.
A 2026 U.S. Supreme Court decision also clarified that federal law does not automatically block these claims. So, depending on the facts, a freight broker can be held liable for a Louisiana truck accident.
What A Broker Does, And Why It Matters
A freight broker arranges a shipment between a shipper and a trucking company. The broker does not own the truck or haul the load. It finds a carrier to move the freight and gets paid for arranging it.
That also means the broker helps choose the carrier. If the broker hires a company with a poor safety record, a history of crashes, lapsed insurance, or revoked operating authority, that decision may become important after a crash.
A negligent-selection claim is based on the idea that the broker failed to use reasonable care when choosing the carrier.
There is another reason the broker may matter in a serious truck accident case. The trucking company’s insurance may not be enough to cover a catastrophic injury. In some cases, the broker may have additional insurance or assets that could help cover the losses.
Get Your Free Consultation
The Preemption Fight, And How It Ended
For years, freight brokers argued that federal law blocked injured people from bringing negligent-selection claims against them under state law.
The issue came down to the Federal Aviation Administration Authorization Act (FAAAA), which limits state laws related to a broker’s prices, routes, and services. The law also has a safety exception that preserves state authority over motor vehicle safety.
Courts disagreed over how that exception applied. The Ninth and Sixth Circuits allowed these claims, while the Seventh and Eleventh Circuits found them preempted.
In 2026, the U.S. Supreme Court settled the issue. It held that negligent-selection claims against freight brokers fall within the safety exception and are not preempted.
What A Louisiana Negligent-Selection Claim Requires
With preemption off the table, you prove the claim under ordinary Louisiana negligence principles.
| Element |
What the injured person must show |
| Duty | The broker owed a duty to use reasonable care in selecting the carrier |
| Breach | The broker hired a carrier it knew or should have known was unsafe |
| Causation | The carrier’s unfitness was a cause of the crash and injuries |
| Damages | The crash caused compensable harm |
The breach is often the key issue. A broker may struggle to show reasonable care if it hired a carrier with an unsatisfactory safety rating, repeated hours-of-service or maintenance violations, inadequate insurance, or revoked authority. The broker’s carrier-vetting records and the carrier’s federal safety history can help show what the broker knew or should have known when it made the decision.
Depending on the facts, other liability theories may also apply. But negligent selection is now a clear path for pursuing a claim against a freight broker.
How It Fits With Louisiana’s Fault And Timing Rules
A broker claim follows the same Louisiana fault and timing rules as other truck accident cases. Since January 1, 2026, a person found 51% or more at fault cannot recover damages under Acts 2025, No. 15. Below 51%, recovery is reduced based on the person’s share of fault. In a broker case, fault can be divided among the driver, carrier, and broker.
For most claims arising after July 1, 2024, Louisiana gives you two years to file under Civil Code article 3493.1. Older claims generally have a one-year limit. The broker may have important records about the carrier, so save those records early.
A broker claim may also help when the carrier’s insurance does not cover the full loss. Our overview of Louisiana truck accident liability explains how liability can be divided among the parties involved.
img-2
Frequently Asked Questions
Is a broker always liable when the carrier crashes?
No. It depends on how the broker chose the carrier. If the broker ignored safety problems it knew or should have known about, it may be held responsible.
Wasn’t federal law used to block these claims?
Yes, that was an issue for years. Courts disagreed about it. In 2026, the Supreme Court ruled that federal preemption does not block negligent-selection claims.
How can I find out if the broker checked the carrier?
The broker may have records showing how it chose the carrier. Federal safety records can also show what the broker could have known at the time.
Why pursue the broker instead of just the trucking company?
The trucking company may not have enough insurance or money to cover a serious injury. The broker may have insurance or other resources that could help cover the remaining losses.
Conclusion
A freight broker may be more than a mediator in a Louisiana truck accident case. If the broker failed to use reasonable care when choosing an unsafe carrier, a negligent-selection claim may be available. The 2026 Supreme Court ruling also removed the federal preemption argument that had blocked these claims in some courts.
If you were seriously injured in a truck crash, Alvendia, Kelly & Demarest can look at how the carrier was selected and whether the broker may be responsible. The firm handles New Orleans truck accident claims and offers free consultations.
Sources
- Congressional Research Service – Does Federal Law Preempt Negligent Selection Claims Against Freight Brokers?
- Justia – Louisiana Civil Code art. 2323, Comparative fault
- Justia – Louisiana Civil Code art. 3493.1, Delictual actions; two-year prescription
Categories
In 2003, after being dissatisfied with the quality of legal care for victims of car accidents, Roderick ‘Rico’ Alvendia sought to establish a new firm focused on providing high-quality legal services to aid injured victims and their families. J. Bart Kelly, sharing Rico’s passion for upholding justice, joined the firm later that year, and established a partnership.




