Partner at AKD Lawyers
Practice Areas: Personal Injury, Insurance Claims
Elevators and escalators are part of daily life in many Louisiana buildings, from office towers to shopping centers. Most people use them without worry, but mechanical failures, unsafe conditions, or poor maintenance can sometimes lead to accidents. When they do, it becomes important to understand how premises responsibility works and who may be responsible under Louisiana law.
This guide explains the key safety rules, common hazards, and what people should know about building responsibility in elevator and escalator incidents.
Overview of Elevator and Escalator Incidents in Louisiana
Elevator and escalator systems are built to handle thousands of trips each year. Still, mechanical parts wear down, sensors malfunction, and spills or debris can create hazardous conditions. These incidents can lead to falls, entrapment, sudden stops, or unexpected movements.
Many of these issues happen because building equipment is not maintained properly. Routine inspections and clear safety practices play a major role in preventing problems.
“Elevators and escalators cause an estimated 17,000 injuries annually in the United States, according to the Consumer Product Safety Commission.”
Accidents can involve misaligned elevator floors, abrupt escalator stops, worn comb plates, or malfunctioning doors. Understanding how these systems work and what can go wrong helps clarify why responsibility matters.
How Premises Responsibility Works in Louisiana
Premises responsibility describes the obligations property owners and custodians have to keep their buildings safe. In Louisiana, this applies to elevators, escalators, and other equipment that may create risk if not properly maintained.
“Louisiana Civil Code Article 2317.1 states that a custodian of a thing is responsible for damage caused by its defective condition if they knew or should have known of the defect and failed to remedy it.”
This means the person or company with control of the equipment may be responsible when a defect or unsafe condition causes harm. It may be a building owner, property management company, or another party with custody of the equipment.
Responsibility also includes making sure maintenance schedules are followed, problems are addressed quickly, and safety guidelines are in place. If warning signs are missing or known issues are ignored, the custodian may be considered responsible for unsafe conditions.
If you’re unsure how responsibility applies in a real-world scenario, speaking with a New Orleans personal injury lawyer can provide clarity about how building safety rules fit into your circumstances.
Common Mechanical Issues in Elevators and Escalators
Elevator and escalator systems contain many moving parts. Problems often occur when maintenance is delayed or components wear out over time.
Elevator malfunctions
- Doors that fail to open or close properly
- Cars stopping between floors
- Unexpected jolts or leveling issues
- Faulty sensors or electrical problems
These issues can lead to trips, falls, or sudden drops. Proper inspection logs help prevent many of these problems.
Escalator hazards
- Sudden stops caused by mechanical failure
- Loose or worn comb plates
- Clothing or shoes caught in moving parts
- Slippery surfaces from spills or debris
Modern escalators depend on functioning handrails, steps, sensors, and stopping mechanisms. When any part fails, users may lose balance or become trapped.
“The ASME A17.1 Safety Code for Elevators and Escalators outlines national safety standards commonly used as a benchmark in building maintenance.”
Conditions That May Lead to Responsibility
Several building conditions can contribute to an accident, especially when maintenance or safety procedures are ignored.
A few common examples include:
- Failure to perform regular inspections or keep accurate maintenance records
- Ignoring known mechanical issues or delaying repairs
Another issue occurs when malfunctioning equipment remains open to the public without warning signs. A simple “out of service” notice can prevent accidents, especially when mechanical defects are obvious to building staff.
Louisiana also follows a comparative fault rule.
“Under Louisiana’s comparative fault rule, an injured person’s recovery may be reduced if they are found partially responsible for the incident.”
This means each situation is reviewed based on its specific details, not assumptions.
Steps to Take After an Elevator or Escalator Accident
Anyone involved in an incident should focus on their health and collect information that helps explain what happened. Clear documentation is important when mechanical equipment is involved.
- Seek medical evaluation- Even mild discomfort can indicate hidden injuries.
- Report the incident- Notify building personnel and ask that an incident report be created. Request a copy for your records.
- Document the scene- Take photos of the elevator or escalator, any debris, malfunctioning parts, or warning signs.
- Collect witness details- Names and brief statements can help clarify what occurred.
- Preserve physical evidence- For example, save torn clothing or shoes if entrapment occurred.
These steps help create a clear picture of how the equipment behaved at the time of the incident.
Understanding Who May Be Responsible
Responsibility for an elevator or escalator accident varies depending on how the equipment is owned, managed, and maintained. More than one party may share responsibility.
The following table outlines common incidents and the parties who may be involved.
Incident Types and Potential Responsible Parties
|
Type of Incident |
Common Cause |
Potentially Responsible Parties |
| Sudden elevator drop | Brake or cable failure | Property owner, maintenance contractor |
| Elevator door malfunction | Sensor or timing issue | Property owner or manager |
| Escalator abrupt stop | Mechanical failure | Property owner, maintenance contractor |
| Entrapment of shoes/clothing | Worn or loose comb plates | Property owner or escalator maintenance firm |
| Slip hazard on escalator | Spills or debris | Property management or cleaning staff |
Understanding responsibility involves reviewing inspection logs, repair timelines, safety signage, and compliance with state building codes.
How Building Codes and Safety Standards Influence Responsibility
Louisiana buildings must follow state building codes, which include requirements for safe operation of elevator and escalator systems. These rules may include inspection frequency, repair timelines, and equipment certification.
Compliance with ASME A17.1 and local safety codes plays a major role in identifying unsafe conditions. Missing inspection certificates or repeated code violations may help show whether equipment was maintained properly.
Buildings that follow required safety guidelines reduce risk for everyone. When they do not, the chances of mechanical failure increase significantly.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the most common causes of elevator and escalator accidents?
Mechanical failures, worn components, debris, electrical issues, or improper maintenance often contribute to sudden stops, misalignment, or entrapment.
What responsibilities do building owners have regarding equipment safety?
Owners must inspect equipment regularly, respond to known problems, display warning signs, and follow state building codes and maintenance standards.
What should someone document after an incident?
Photograph the scene, collect witness details, request an incident report, and note anything unusual such as debris, noises, jolts, or malfunctioning doors.
How does Louisiana’s comparative fault rule apply?
Each party is assigned a percentage of responsibility. Any recovery may be reduced based on how much the injured person contributed to the incident.
Can multiple parties be responsible for a single incident?
Yes. Owners, managers, maintenance contractors, cleaning staff, or manufacturers may all share responsibility depending on the mechanical issue.
Conclusion
Elevator and escalator accidents often involve mechanical issues, worn equipment, or unsafe building conditions. Louisiana’s civil code outlines when a property owner or custodian may be responsible for a defect, and understanding these rules helps clarify how incidents occur. Clear documentation, early medical evaluation, and awareness of inspection practices all play important roles in protecting your well-being.
If you or someone you know was involved in an elevator or escalator accident and wants to understand available options, the team at Alvendia, Kelly & Demarest Law Firm is here to help. You can request a free consultation to discuss your situation and get guidance tailored to your needs.
Categories
In 2003, after being dissatisfied with the quality of legal care for victims of car accidents, Roderick ‘Rico’ Alvendia sought to establish a new firm focused on providing high-quality legal services to aid injured victims and their families. J. Bart Kelly, sharing Rico’s passion for upholding justice, joined the firm later that year, and established a partnership.
